It is also designed as a comprehensive counterprogram to david lewis program of humean supervenience. Understanding explanation, oxford university press, 2004, 122. Setup explannation account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your universitys proxy server configure custom proxy use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy. Cambridge core epistemology and metaphysics causation and explanation by stathis psillos. Develop an idea for a philosophical reflection on sciences word. And can there be an adequate theory of explanation. It is shown how they are able to identify causal relevance on the basis of eliminative. Our goal will be to look at four main approaches to causation.
Proof of causation in tort law provides a critical, comparative and theoretical analysis of the general proof rules of causation underlying the tort laws of england, germany and france, as well as the exceptional departures from these rules which each system has made. An exclusively reductive explanation could bring a loss of information, since it. Indeed, some commentators take hume to hold that causation is a matter of real, fully mindindependent necessary connections. Epsa19 programme epsa19 programme 16 17 quantum gravity and cosmology prediction and laws s. English spanish online dictionary term bank, translate.
Bibliography on causation in comparative criminal law. Hpscga28 knowledge explanation and classification syllabus session 20172018 term 1. Rather than defining causality purely in reference to observable events, counterfactual models define causation in terms of a comparison of observable and unobservable events. In part iii, we present three main approaches to laws of. Lanham, david, principles of causation in criminal law, in ian r. Integrate these topics with related theoretical concepts from. This means that explanation and prediction are more or less the same thing. Previous generations of sociologists who have taken courses in the. In the section on laws of nature, psillos considers both the regularity view of laws and laws as relations among universals as well as alternative approaches to laws.
Stathis psillos stathis psillos philosophy of science. In the section on laws of nature, psillos considers both the regularity view of laws and laws as relations among universals as well as alternative approaches to. More concretely, there are two types and hence two logics of experiment in biology and medicine. Challenges in understanding the causality of simple circuits. Causation and explanation central problems of philosophy and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle. His book causation and explanation acumen,2002 has received the british society for the. Causation, physics, and the constitution of reality. Causation and explanation central problems of philosophy. In the philosophy of mind, philosophers want to know whether and how the mind can be. Causatiob 1 of this book explores humes views on causation, theories of singular causation, and counterfactual and mechanistic approaches.
Aims and objectives aims to provide knowledge of the 3 core topics. Thursday 1pm 3pm outside office hour only by appointment, please email. Philosophy of science az philosophy az eup stathis psillos on amazon. Advanced topics in philosophy of science course guide 201617. The p have to prove it is fair to blame the d for the criminal act caused by his conduct. I argue for the causal character of modeling in dataintensive science, contrary to widespread claims that big data is only concerned with the search for correlations. In part ii, we browse the voluminous literature on causation in a very selective way. Qualitative work and the testing and development of theory. If both tests are proved by the p the d can be blamed for the ar of an offence. Abstract accounts of ontic explanation have often been devised so as to provide an understanding of mechanism and of causation. Think for instance of the coveringlaw approaches, such as hempels deductivenomological model or dnmodel. How the modalities come into the world springerlink.
Causation and causal explanation, in his explanation and understanding cornell up. To provide some foundational philosophy of science material. After a physics degree in the university of patras, greece, i was awarded in 1989 a scholarship from the greek states scholarship foundation to study philosophy. Ontic accounts differ quite radically in their ontologies, and one of the latest additions to this tradition proposed by peter machamer, lindley darden and carl craver reintroduces the concept of activity. Russells republic revisited edited by huw price and richard. Hume and the problem of causation research explorer. Psillos, stathis, 1965 causation and explanation stathis psillos. From explanation to causation and back again david lagnado thinking about evidence paolo vineis the nature of medical theories and conditionalized realism 10. How science tracks truth, routledge, 1999 research interests philosophy of science, epistemology, metaphysics, history of philosophy of science the best way to get in touch with me is by sending me an email. His book causation and explanation acumen, 2002 has received the british society for the philosophy of science.
Causation and explanation by stathis psillos, philosophical books, 45 2004. Science, nature and social values course guide 201718 course organiser. Defendingdeductivenomology stathis psillos, causation and. Randall collins 2 choices the idea of the glass ceiling is a good example. Hpsc0085 knowledge explanation and classification course.
For my story about general or typelevel causation, drawing on the same ideas as the singular story, see strevens oy, a. Collins, on the other hand, lets us see that the conflict around stratified resources has a strong symbolic character. Queens college, accessions list, march 2017 add sy 8m joo joostgaugier, christiane l. Inference to the best explanation, coherence and other explanatory virtues. Causal explanation proceeds by citing the causes of the explanandum. Stathis psillos 6 causation and the sciences 96 ned hall 7 scienti. Thus this paper is a statement of humean projectivism. Science, nature and social values course guide 201718. Accordingly, bertrand russell 18721970 claimed that causation is a relic from a bygone age, surviving, like the monarchy, only because it is erroneously supposed to do no harm. Causation, dispositions, and divine action walter schultz, phd and lisanne winslow, phd 5. Course aims and objectives this course gives an introduction to some central issues in contemporary philosophy of science.
In press manuscript at european journal of personality behavior genetic frameworks of causal reasoning for personality psychology daniel a. Stathis psillos in the section on laws of nature, psillos considers both the regularity view of laws and laws as relations among universals as well as alternative approaches to laws. So an adequate explanation of an event should offer an adequate understanding of the event psillos 2002, p. Hpsc0085 knowledge explanation and classification course syllabus. Three senses of the word cause,in an essay on metaphysics clarendon press. Introduction this paper provides a conceptualization of causation and dispositions on the grounds of a new view of divine action. Scientists try to develop the best methods for finding causation. Defendingdeductivenomology stathis psillos, causation and explanation. Although this book takes only the latter two words. Notwithstanding the ease with which it can be shown that simple persisting regularities are not generally sufficient to ground a causal claim psillos, 2002, humes regularity view of causation has seemed to underlie much quantitative social science 4 pawson, 1989, 2008. Scientific realism usually holds that science makes. As becomes clear below, the two logics of experiment hold very different ideas of ideal experiment or intervention.
Knowledge transfer ad its context predrag sustar and vito balorda. In response, realists such as stathis psillos 1999 have argued that we should accept the ontological posits of scientific theories only where the relevant science is mature, in the kuhnian sense, and where the theory in question generates successful novel predictions, in a way which centrally involves the ontological posits at stake. We use disposition generically to refer to what many are calling active and passive causal powers. After discussing the concept of dataintensive science and introducing two examples as illustration, several algorithms are examined. Hume and the problem of causation the university of. In other words, neoaristotelianism is supposed to win on the basis of an inference to the best explanation ibe. In press manuscript at european journal of personality. Towards a philosophy of sustainability science refreshments surface 2 5 refreshments surface 2 5 microbiology s. According to the dnmodel, an explanation consists of an explanandum e a description of the phenomenon to be explained and an explanans the statements that do the. The causal nature of modeling with big data springerlink.
In the final section on explanation he examines in detail the issues arising from deductivenomological explanation and statistical explanation before considering. Passages like these suggest that philosophers of science have recognized, at least implicitly, the attractiveness of the. It is shown how they are able to identify causal relevance on. A very short introduction by stephen mumford and rani lill anjum questions for thought and discussion how important is causation for all sciences and the humanities. Introduction it is in good part due to hume that causation has been regarded as problematic by analytic philosophers in the last hundred years or so. When can one jump from correlation to causation in order to explain a phenomenon and what is a causal explanation. In psilllos final section on explanation he examines in detail the issues arising from deductivenomological explanation and statistical explanation in the section on laws of nature, psillos considers both the regularity view of laws and laws as relations among universals as well as alternative approaches to laws. Any model of causal explanation requires a specification of the relation between cause.
Reproductions supplied by edrs are the best that can be made. Introduction thomas brown 17781820 was one of the tailenders of the scottish enlightenment. Causality study fortnight programme introductory lectures. Part 1 of this book explores humes views on causation, theories of singular causation, and counterfactual and mechanistic approaches. Advanced topics in philosophy of science course guide 2016. The theoretical concepts will be grounded in case studies from scientific practice. By james ladyman in recent years philosophy of science has seen a resurgence of interest in metaphysical issues, especially those concerning laws, causation,and explanation. The case of smoking as causing cancer maria kronfeldner michele luchetti reading. In experiments within the population logic, the ideal experiment is to facilitate the isolation or identification of the causal effect. This article argues that these two approaches are underpinned by two logics of experiment. The basic arguments of this chapter are that i acts of crime are moral actions and thereforeneedtobeanalysed andexplained assuchandiiexplaining actsofcrimeisnotdifferent from explaining breaches of moral rules more generally the explanatory process is the same.
Service in the duke university department of philosophy selection director of graduate studies before 1990. The interpretative problems encountered when we try to make sense of what hume says about causation are the main focus of this chapter. Counterfactual models of causation regularity models of causation have largely been abandoned in favor of counterfactual models. I am a friend of ibe a cardcarrying member of the club, but i fail to see how it can be used to favour neoaristotelianism over neohumeanism. How science tracks truth 1999, causation and explanation 2002 and philosophy. Students typically have misconceptions about how simple circuits work. Jun 19, 2015 i argue for the causal character of modeling in dataintensive science, contrary to widespread claims that big data is only concerned with the search for correlations. Lengua fisurada pdf english translation, synonyms, definitions and usage examples of spanish word lengua fisurada.
Causation, miscellaneous in metaphysics categorize this paper. Wk 2 causation and presuppositions student presentations collingwood, r. Calling big data the new science of complexity, he refutes the notion that. Foundations of contemporary metaphysics by cynthia macdonald, philosophical books, 48 2007.
In the philosophy of mind, philosophers want to know whether and how the mind can be said to have causal efficacy, and in. Students will be encouraged to think about other case studies. Stathis psillos, causation and explanation philpapers. Curriculum vitae personal information duke university. When can one generalize the result one derived in a specific study and what is the danger in doing so. Part 1 of the book explores humes views on causation, theories of singular causation, and counterfactual and mechanistic approaches. These questions and many others are addressed in this unified.
According to the dnmodel, an explanation consists of an explanandum e a. The modalities come into the world by being projections or objectivizations of our epistemic constitution. He shared with dugald stewart 17531828 the chair of moral philosophy at the university of edinburgh from 1810 until his premature death in 1820. Activitybased accounts of mechanism and the threat of. Stathis psillosis associate professor in the department of philosophy and history of science at the university of athens,greece.
125 727 628 2 208 505 1086 1268 1115 1526 749 271 962 1066 1269 1346 1379 616 125 204 327 1529 1621 1157 1007 564 1402 548 413 157 263 470 1449 496